Very, in order to find their enneagram method of, you first must admit that you’re below average somehow and other. ” When you find yourself a questionnaire 1, you happen to be prideful; while a form 2 you happen to be lustful; and so forth. Claiming the enneatype matches proclaiming which emotional situation you’ve dropped victim in order to.
Instantly, we see a sharp contrast between your enneagram additionally the MBTI. While it’s correct that Jung try a doctor whoever works are mainly that have substandard customers, their design was nonetheless according to match someone. Isabel Myers took Jung’s eight “cognitive choice,” broke up you to model out of the rest of his writing, and you will developed a tool made to identify such fit personalities. Brand new MBTI is definitely utilized in the brand new areas away from providers, knowledge, and you will go out-to-date lives as a means of codifying normal mans personalities. There aren’t any value judgments; zero type is preferable to any other type, nor can there be a good “sinful” otherwise “diseased” element of people identification type of.
The complete push of your MBTI (basically of Keirsey’s temperament principle) should be to choose identification products for example facilitate telecommunications and you will wisdom ranging from individuals. It could be–and regularly is–misused so you’re able to label some one and you may foster bigotry; but that’s only a misuse of the system that is inspired by ignorance.
Therefore for me personally (unless I am hopelessly in a state off assertion), the enneagram is largely counterproductive
The thrust of your own enneagram is always to identify simple human flaws otherwise failings (sins or character conditions). Displayed within the greatest white, the objective might be to indicate unhealthy members of this new guidelines away from higher fitness. But in one instance, the brand new initial step is actually, “There will be something wrong to you.” To buy with the that’s certain and also make a man become faulty. More over, it is certain to make enneagram practitioner select every person while the bad as well. On and front, that may help people undertake their and you can others’ regulations and decide on worry about-upgrade. But towards the downside it calls awareness of people’s deep properties; it accentuates this new negative.
For my situation, it is really not an extremely helpful highway map
Exactly as really a Christians prevent preaching fire and brimstone, most enneagram followers stop in public areas revealing the darker area of the enneagram. Enneagram guides and you will talk teams are full of humor and you will friendly anecdotes. Some enneagram editors come across as upbeat due to the fact Dr. Phil. But one another Dr. Phil as well as the enneagram fundamentally work on below average perceptions and you may conclusion. The brand new logic is apparently, “if you aren’t sick, we simply cannot american bride improve you; so basic you must pick one from 9 categories of infection.”
It could be a very important thing if the enneagram have been in a position to augment people–however it are unable to. It is nothing more than a diagram having accompanying descriptions of personality at different degrees of health. This may promote of good use yardsticks getting relieving schizophrenics or people who have most other personality issues; however, even those individuals are going to need way more help than simply it to actually get well. New enneagram is not a healing strategy; it’s simply a diagram–a sort of highway map in order to healing.
Full, I might state I’m damn match. I would personally need to offer my imagination and you will guess particular shade off problems, following start looking for a method to reduce that condition. Meanwhile, I’m more likely to become significantly more worry about-immersed, that’s likely to continue myself from communicating with and you will skills others as they really are.
Hang around an enneagram talk category for any timeframe, and you may soon end up being you are in some type of recuperation class. Some individuals grab satisfaction within enneatypes, but the majority acknowledge he’s got troubles and they are looking to recover out-of men and women trouble. And when they do recover, a lot of them feel the enneagram will no longer suffice any helpful mission. Immediately after men will get healthy, the newest enneagram will get irrelevant.